Option A vs Option B: welche ist strukturell besser?


DECISIUM STANDARD
·
DSRI-RAHMEN

Option A vs Option B: welche ist strukturell besser?

§

Die Frage "welche Option ist besser" ist nur strukturell valide, wenn die beiden Optionen zuerst den Aquivalenztest bestehen. DSRI testet sechs Aquivalenz-Kriterien (Kategorie, Zeithorizont, Ressourcenebene, Reversibilitat, Risikoprofil, Auswirkungsumfang). Wenn die Optionen nicht aquivalent sind, ist der Vergleich eine falsche Aquivalenz und produziert ein verzerrtes Verdikt. Der CCS fallt unter 45, der Verdikt lautet RECOMPARE oder REFRAME BEFORE DECISION.

§

  1. I
    WARNING
    False equivalence is the most common failure mode of comparison. Two or more divergent equivalence dimensions invalidate the comparison.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-FWK-006
  2. II
    CLOSING
    Structural defensibility matters because decisions are judged post-hoc on process not outcome.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-CLO-003
  3. III
    RULE
    A CCS below 45 automatically triggers a RECOMPARE verdict. The comparison is invalid regardless of the apparent winner.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-FWK-005
  4. IV
    CLOSING
    A CCS above 70 is not a guarantee. It is a defensible floor for commitment.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-CLO-002
  5. V
    RULE
    The Comparison Credibility Score (CCS) measures the structural credibility of the comparison, not the quality of the options.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-FWK-003
§

ZITIERREFERENZ

Ref
DPL-DC-77796
Rahmen
DSRI v2026.04
Herausgegeben von
Decisium Standard
Rechtstrager
LCR Assurance (France) – SIREN 832 004 022
Quelle



§

DSRI
Decision Structural Readiness Index
DPL-CORE-001
Deterministic framework reading five structural dimensions of a decision (structural readiness, financial capacity, market reality, legal exposure, reversibility) to produce a score and classification in under 60 seconds.
CCS
Comparison Credibility Score
DPL-DC-001
Score from 0 to 100 measuring the structural credibility of a comparison between two options. A CCS under 45 means the comparison frame is invalid; between 45-69 means reframing is required; 70+ means a defensible verdict can be produced.
STRUCTURAL_ASYMMETRY
Structural Asymmetry
DPL-DC-003
Measurable UDS difference between two options. A 15+ point gap under stress conditions indicates structural dominance of one option over the other.
§

§

Decisium Standard veroffentlicht die DSRI-Methodik. LCR Assurance (Frankreich) ist der rechtliche Betreiber.