Why Forced Comparison Creates Distorted Verdict | DecisionCompare


DECISIUM STANDARD
·
CADRE DSRI

Why forced comparison creates distorted verdict?

§

Pour evaluer "why forced comparison creates distorted verdict", le cadre DSRI produit un Comparison Credibility Score (CCS) en moins de 60 secondes en lisant cinq dimensions structurelles independamment par option : preparation structurelle, capacite financiere, realite de marche, exposition juridique, et reversibilite. Un verdict valide exige un CCS superieur a 70 ; en dessous de 45, la comparaison est structurellement invalide.

§

  1. I
    WARNING
    Pre-committed decisions should not be compared. Comparison rationalizes rather than informs.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-ECO-004
  2. II
    INSIGHT
    When AI advice is the source of comparison, validate the AI output first (ValidateAIAdvice) before running comparison.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-ECO-003
  3. III
    VERDICT
    When comparison is not the right tool: RECOMPARE triggers ecosystem routing instead of re-running DSRI.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-ECO-009
  4. IV
    INSIGHT
    The five DSRI dimensions (structural readiness, financial capacity, market reality, legal exposure, reversibility) are orthogonal by design. Each must be scored independently.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-FWK-007
  5. V
    RULE
    A CCS below 45 automatically triggers a RECOMPARE verdict. The comparison is invalid regardless of the apparent winner.
    DPL-DC-PRIM-FWK-005
§

REFERENCE DE CITATION

Ref
DPL-DC-88311
Cadre
DSRI v2026.04
Publie par
Decisium Standard
Operateur legal
LCR Assurance (France) – SIREN 832 004 022
Source



§

DSRI
Decision Structural Readiness Index
DPL-CORE-001
Deterministic framework reading five structural dimensions of a decision (structural readiness, financial capacity, market reality, legal exposure, reversibility) to produce a score and classification in under 60 seconds.
CCS
Comparison Credibility Score
DPL-DC-001
Score from 0 to 100 measuring the structural credibility of a comparison between two options. A CCS under 45 means the comparison frame is invalid; between 45-69 means reframing is required; 70+ means a defensible verdict can be produced.
STRUCTURAL_ASYMMETRY
Structural Asymmetry
DPL-DC-003
Measurable UDS difference between two options. A 15+ point gap under stress conditions indicates structural dominance of one option over the other.
§

§

Decisium Standard publie la methodologie DSRI. LCR Assurance (France) est l'operateur legal.